top of page
Search

How to Choose the Right Therapist for You: A Complete Guide



ree

By Davenport Counseling — Your No-nonsense Therapists, where we're Better Together


Finding a therapist is one of the most personal and powerful steps you can take for your mental health. Whether you're seeking support for anxiety, depression, trauma, life transitions, or simply personal growth, choosing the right therapist can make all the difference.


But with thousands of professionals offering a wide range of specialties and approaches, how do you find the right match?


At Davenport Counseling, we believe therapy should be approachable, honest, and tailored to your needs. In this guide, we walk you through the essentials of choosing a therapist who feels right for you.


Why the Right Therapist Matters

The therapeutic relationship—the connection between you and your therapist—is a major predictor of therapy success. It’s not just about credentials or techniques. It’s about trust, understanding, and fit.


That’s why here at Davenport Counseling, we prioritize clarity, mutual respect, and no-nonsense support. We're committed to helping clients find real, sustainable change through meaningful connection.


Step 1: Define Your Needs and Goals


Start by asking yourself:

  • What are my biggest challenges right now?

  • What type of therapy might I benefit from—individual, couples, family, or group?

  • Do I want a practical problem-solving approach or deeper emotional work?

  • Would I prefer a therapist who shares or understands my background, culture, or values?

Knowing what you want from therapy helps you connect with a therapist who can deliver that.


At Davenport Counseling, we begin every client relationship with honest conversation. 


Step 2: Know Your Therapist Types


There are several types of licensed therapists:

  • Psychologists (PhD/PsyD): Experts in mental health diagnosis and therapy.

  • Psychiatrists (MD/DO): Medical doctors who can prescribe medication.

  • LCSWs: Licensed Clinical Social Workers trained in therapy and systems support.

  • LPCs/LMHCs: Licensed Counselors who provide talk therapy.

  • LMFTs: Trained specifically in family and relationship dynamics.


At Davenport Counseling, we bring together a team of credentialed professionals who balance clinical expertise with no-nonsense compassion.


Step 3: Explore Therapeutic Approaches


Not all therapists use the same style. Some of the most common approaches include:

  • CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy): Challenge negative thought patterns.

  • DBT (Dialectical Behavior Therapy): Manage emotions and interpersonal conflict.

  • Psychodynamic: Explore past experiences to understand present behavior.

  • EMDR: Target and reprocess traumatic memories.

  • Humanistic or Integrative: Focus on personal growth and authenticity.


We use evidence-based methods at Davenport Counseling, but we never take a cookie-cutter approach. We match techniques to your goals—and explain what we’re doing every step of the way.


Because therapy should feel like progress, not a mystery.


Step 4: Start Your Search


Use Trusted Directories:

Or Contact Us Directly


If you're in our region or looking for virtual therapy, Davenport Counseling, Your No-nonsense Therapists where we're Better Together, is ready to meet you where you are. Our team is accessible, transparent, and passionate about creating positive change.


Step 5: Consider the Practical Details


Ask yourself:

  • Do I want in-person or virtual sessions?

  • Does the therapist accept my insurance?

  • Can I afford the sessions or access sliding-scale pricing?

  • Do their availability and office hours work for me?


A good fit isn’t just emotional—it’s logistical. We make that easy at Davenport Counseling with clear scheduling, fair pricing, and no guesswork.


Step 6: Schedule a Consultation


Many therapists (including us) offer a free 30 minute initial consultation. This is your chance to:

  • Ask questions

  • Share your goals

  • Get a feel for their personality and communication style

Here are great questions to ask:

  • Have you worked with people facing issues like mine?

  • How would you describe your therapy style?

  • How do you track progress?

  • What’s your cancellation policy?


At Davenport Counseling, we welcome these conversations. We’re here to earn your trust, not assume it.


Step 7: Listen to Your Gut


After a session or two, reflect on your experience:

  • Do you feel safe and understood?

  • Are you being challenged, supported, or both?

  • Does the therapist seem engaged and responsive?

  • Are sessions helping you move forward?


If not, it’s okay to keep looking. You deserve to feel empowered and comfortable in therapy. As we often say at Davenport Counseling: You don’t have to settle—we’ll help you find a fit that works.


Step 8: Be Open to Change


Not every therapist will be right—and that’s okay.


Reasons to try a different provider:

  • You don’t feel heard or respected.

  • Your therapist isn’t responsive to your feedback.

  • You're not seeing meaningful progress.

  • Their approach doesn't align with your goals.


We know switching can be uncomfortable, but we’re here to make transitions smoother. At Davenport Counseling, we’d rather see you thrive elsewhere than stay stuck.


Because we believe in collaboration—and we truly are Better Together.


Special Considerations


Cultural Sensitivity

If you’re part of a marginalized group, seek a therapist who values and understands your lived experience. Cultural competence builds safety and depth in therapy.


Trauma-Informed Care

If you’ve experienced trauma, look for someone who works through a trauma-informed lens. We specialize in creating emotionally safe spaces and helping clients rebuild trust in themselves and others.


Faith, Gender Identity, or Life Stage

Whether you're seeking a faith-affirming therapist, gender-affirming support, or just someone who gets what it’s like to balance parenting, career, and personal health—we’ve got someone for you.


At Davenport Counseling, our no-nonsense approach includes honoring all aspects of your identity and life experience.


Final Thoughts: It’s Okay to Take Your Time

Therapy is a relationship, and like all relationships, it takes time to build trust. Don’t rush it. You’re allowed to try different therapists, ask questions, and put your well-being first.

And if you're still unsure where to start?

Let’s talk. Davenport Counseling, Your No-nonsense Therapists where we're Better Together, offers approachable, honest, and effective therapy for real people navigating real life.


No jargon. No judgment. Just results, empathy, and support.


Ready to Start? Here's How:


Remember, the right therapist is out there—and your healing journey is worth every step.


At Davenport Counseling, we're here for the real conversations that lead to real change. Because when therapy is grounded in honesty, empathy, and partnership, we're truly Better Together.

 

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page